Not all roofing materials are created equal. Some will last for decades with minimal maintenance, while others will have you calling a roofer way too often. If you’re thinking about getting a new roof, avoid making a costly mistake by choosing the wrong material. Let’s talk about the worst option out there and why you should steer clear.
The Worst Choice: Cheap 3-Tab Asphalt Shingles
If you’re on a budget, 3-tab asphalt shingles might look like an easy choice. They’re cheap, widely available, and technically do the job. But in reality, they’re one of the worst long-term investments you can make for your home.
Why 3-Tab Shingles Are a Bad Idea
- Short Lifespan – While higher-quality shingles last 30+ years, 3-tab shingles barely make it to 15 years—and that’s with perfect weather conditions.
- Easily Damaged by Wind & Storms – Strong winds can rip these shingles right off your roof. If you live anywhere with storms, hurricanes, or even occasional high winds, they won’t hold up.
- Poor Insulation = Higher Energy Bills – These shingles absorb a ton of heat in the summer and don’t provide much insulation in the winter. Translation? Your HVAC system works harder, and your energy bills go up.
- Moss & Algae Growth – Because they retain moisture, they’re a magnet for moss, algae, and mold—giving your roof that dreaded streaky, green look.
- Low Resale Value – If you plan on selling your home, a 3-tab shingle roof won’t impress buyers. Many see it as a cheap, temporary solution and will negotiate a lower price.
Better Roofing Alternatives
If you want a roof that lasts, consider upgrading to:
- Architectural Shingles – A stronger, longer-lasting version of asphalt shingles that offers better wind resistance and a more attractive look.
- Metal Roofing – More expensive upfront, but lasts 40+ years, reflects heat, and requires minimal maintenance.
- Tile or Slate – The best for longevity (50+ years), but heavy and requires a strong roof structure to support it.
The Bottom Line
3-tab asphalt shingles might save you money upfront, but they’ll cost you more in the long run with repairs, replacements, and energy bills. If you’re investing in a new roof, spend a little more now on a material that will actually protect your home—and your wallet—for decades to come. Because let’s be honest, nobody wants to replace their roof twice in 20 years.
Picture Credit: Freepik